When a patient asks AI for a surgeon, does it name you?
Patients now ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google and Claude for a shortlist. Read your own in three steps: ask the questions patients type, check that the engines can read your site, and publish facts about yourself that you have checked and signed.
Start here: step 1. No account. Your tally stays on this device. Nothing here writes reviews, buys a listing or promises a placement; no one can promise that.
1. Read your shortlist
Answers change nearly every time. In SparkToro and Gumshoe's test (2,961 runs on ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI, November and December 2025) there was less than a 1-in-100 chance of the same list twice (report). So count how often you are named, never where you rank, and ask each question more than once.
ProcedureAsk about the big city too, not only your own town. A surgeon can be named for the suburb they practice in and missed for the city twenty minutes away.
QuestionsEnginesHow to ask, so the runs can be compared
- Signed out, or in a private window. A signed-in engine answers from what it knows about you.
- A new conversation for every run. No follow-up questions.
- Paste the question exactly as written. Do all the runs on the same day.
- Tap “Named” only if the answer recommends you by name.
Add a city to build the list.
2. Can the engines read your site?
This is the one fix that can be checked for certain. Each engine sends its own crawler, and a site can block a search crawler without knowing it. Blocking a training crawler is your choice and does not remove you from search answers.
The address goes to SurgeonValue's server, which reads that site's public robots.txt once. Nothing is stored.
3. Your facts, for you to sign
Engines and directories copy what public records say about you. Start from your CMS NPPES record, keep or strike each line, add what only you can vouch for, and publish the block on your own site. Every line comes from NPPES or from you; nothing is written for you.
The NPI goes to SurgeonValue's server, which asks the public CMS NPPES registry. Nothing is stored.
What this cannot do, and what to stay away from
- No one can promise that an engine will name you, or in what place. Be wary of anyone who does.
- Never write, buy or gate reviews. The FTC's rule on fake reviews took effect October 21, 2024 (FTC). Ask every patient the same way, or ask none.
- Never hide text or instructions on a page for an AI to read. It is deception, and engines treat it that way.
- “Best” and “#1” need a named, checkable source. The AAOS opinion on advertising treats an unsupported superlative as deception (AAOS), and state boards set their own rules.
- An llms.txt file has shown no measured effect on which doctors are named; Google says its search ignores it. It does no harm, but it is not a lever.
- Outcome numbers belong on a page only with their source and case count. There is no public, surgeon-level knee outcome file today; hospital measures on CMS Care Compare are about the hospital.
Next: check your payer directory listing, the other public record about you that patients and plans read.